August 21, 2013
Free PDF Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel
Now, just how do you understand where to purchase this publication Drawing Fire: Investigating The Accusations Of Apartheid In Israel Never mind, now you could not visit guide shop under the bright sun or night to look guide Drawing Fire: Investigating The Accusations Of Apartheid In Israel We right here always aid you to locate hundreds kinds of publication. Among them is this publication qualified Drawing Fire: Investigating The Accusations Of Apartheid In Israel You could go to the web link page provided in this set and after that go for downloading and install. It will certainly not take more times. Simply hook up to your net accessibility as well as you can access the book Drawing Fire: Investigating The Accusations Of Apartheid In Israel on-line. Of course, after downloading and install Drawing Fire: Investigating The Accusations Of Apartheid In Israel, you may not publish it.
Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel
Free PDF Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel
Currently, invite the book vendor that will come to be the most effective vendor book today. This is it publication. You may not feel that you are not aware of this publication, may you? Yeah, practically everybody understands about this publication. It will additionally go through just how the book is actually offered. When you can make the opportunity of guide with the good one, you can pick it based on the factor as well as referral of just how guide will be.
Many duties in this current era require the book not only from the current publication, yet also from the old book collections. Why not? We offer you all collections from the earliest to the latest books in the world libraries. So, it is extremely finished. When you really feel that the book that you have is actually publication that you want to review currently, it's so pleasured. Yet, we truly suggest you to review Drawing Fire: Investigating The Accusations Of Apartheid In Israel for your own need.
One to be factor of why you should pick this publication can be acquired when you're starting. Additionally, when completing this book, you could really feel various life. What sort of difference? It will additionally depend on your selection to alter your life. Yet, as a matter of fact this Drawing Fire: Investigating The Accusations Of Apartheid In Israel come to be several of the most wanted book in the world. It provides you not only experience yet also the new expertise.
When someone can deliver the existence of this publication, you could get this publication immediately. It will certainly not need sometimes, once again. It will provide you ease means. This best sold book from the best writer really comes to bone of desired as well as desired publication to motivate. Drawing Fire: Investigating The Accusations Of Apartheid In Israel as the new publication could join this world correctly. And now, follow us to obtain this amazing publication.
Review
If you want an informed opinion about whether Israel is an apartheid state. . . .Benjamin Pogrund is worth reading. (The Citizen)[Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel] . . . will be valuable to anyone who genuinely seeks an understanding of the real situation on the ground, behind the political rhetoric. (South African Jewish Report)At its best this book succeeds in providing valuable empirical resources that will enable its readers to question the totalising and distorted representations of the Israel-Palestine conflict that the apartheid analogy requires. . . .Drawing Fire is . . . most illuminating when it provides its readers with the information and argument that helps us understand the current conflict and the injustices to ordinary people that accompany it. . . .[In] spite of the author’s own best intentions, he is clearly worried that the occupation and settlement of Palestine is leading toward a situation in which the apartheid analogy looks more persuasive. The growth of a militant and loud anti-Arab racism within both the Israeli polity and society is a product of occupation that does not justify the apartheid analogy but may feed it if we are not careful. There is plenty to chew on in this worthy book. (Fathom)[T]he book succeeds in his primary goal of showing that although there are some broad similarities between apartheid and Israeli reality, including the OPT, the term apartheid is simply not applicable to the latter. . . .Pogrund’s book is an eloquent statement of what some call 'liberal Zionism,' a humanistically based philosophy that advocates a sovereign state for Palestinians and equal rights for those with Israeli citizenship. . . .[T]he book is valuable as a statement of both hope and reality: that Israel retains the basis of a humanistically inclined country, that it is not an 'apartheid state,' and as an explication of what both Zionism and Israeli reality are and are not. (Palestine-Israel Journal)This is an essential read for everyone who wants to persuasively confront the BDS movement. (Jewish Book Council)What lends credence to Pogrund’s book are his impeccable anti-apartheid credentials…. From the late 1950s through the mid-1980s, a period covering the heyday of apartheid, he emerged as one of the most persistent and courageous journalists to expose the iniquities of that system, including the brutal suppression of political dissent by those it targeted…. Although drawing parallels between apartheid-era South Africa and modern-day Israel is damaging and misleading, Pogrund is among those who believe that Israelis and Palestinians can still learn from how South Africans successfully negotiated an end to apartheid and made a peaceful transition to non-racial democracy. (Israel Journal of Foreign Affairs)Benjamin Pogrund, a foremost journalist in the struggle against apartheid and in more recent years an ardent worker for peace and social concern in Israel, brings to this study peerless qualifications for comparing the controversial historical experience of South Africa and Israel. With a combination of compassion, analytical insight, and judicious balance he unravels the welter of crass ignorance and malevolence that bedevils the contemporary polemic. (Prof. Gideon Shimoni, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem)A serious, thoughtful, engaging and timely intervention amidst a flood of ahistorical and tendentious nonsense. Benjamin Pogrund, a renowned journalist, knows both Israel and Apartheid South Africa well. Brutally honest, he exposes crude and simplistic analogies while not shying away from the harshness of Israeli rule in the occupied territories. A must for those with an interest in comparative analysis. (Prof. Milton Shain, University of Cape Town)On several lecture tours to South Africa with Benjamin Pogrund I have listened to him say there is no comparison between apartheid and the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Although telling the truth can draw fire, he tells the truth. This book is about truth. (Bassem Eid, Palestinian Human Rights Monitoring Group)This enquiry harshly condemns Israel’s settlement policy and oppressive practices in the Occupied Palestinian Territories yet places them outside the context of apartheid, showing how apartheid allegations have often been cynically used to delegitimize Israel’s very right to exist. Benjamin Pogrund, with skillful balance and painful honesty, demonstrates the complexity of the issues of war, occupation, terrorism, settlements, discrimination and the human tragedy of two peoples woven into the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. (Prof. Frances Raday, Concord Research Center for Integration of International Law in Israel)
Read more
Review
While many label Israel ‘an apartheid state’, Benjamin Pogrund actually experienced apartheid, from Sharpeville to Mandela’s liberation. He is therefore well placed to dissect the easy analogy between Zionist Israel and apartheid South Africa. This critical and detailed account of the complexity of Israel’s situation will not please some, but it will be an eye-opener for many who have hitherto accepted the conventional wisdom. For those who do not think in monochrome, this is an important book. (Colin Shindler, SOAS, University of London)
Read more
See all Editorial Reviews
Product details
Hardcover: 360 pages
Publisher: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers (July 10, 2014)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1442226838
ISBN-13: 978-1442226838
Product Dimensions:
6.3 x 1.2 x 9.3 inches
Shipping Weight: 1.4 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review:
4.1 out of 5 stars
5 customer reviews
Amazon Best Sellers Rank:
#1,572,373 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
I had just finished reading Benjamin Pogrund’s book and I would recommend it to people who are interested in learning about the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. This conflict is very complex and Israel is often accused of being an apartheid state. Benjamin Pogrund was editor of the Rand Daily Mail, a South African newspaper that was closed down in 1985, and he himself has a thorough knowledge of apartheid. He had been arrested and banned for his views and activities against apartheid. His passport was taken away from him a number of times. Eventually, it was returned to him and he emigrated to Israel where he founded the Yakar movement for peace and coexistence. He had researched his book by interviewing many Palestinians and Israelis. He starts his book giving a precis of his life and activities in South Africa as well as a short history of the Jewish People and their sufferings in Europe because of anti-Semitism over the centuries culminating in Israel’s establishment.The book at times is heavy going because of the incredible amount of statistics he gives on demography and other issues which he felt the reader should be aware.He also writes about South Africa under the White Apartheid Government. He is the ideal writer for a book as complex as this. He knows apartheid very well because of what he had experienced and he knows the Israeli psyche very well too. He does criticize Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians under their rule as well their suffering under occupation. Despite that, he maintains it is still far from apartheid.Pogrund refutes the argument that Israel is an apartheid state and he gives very good and convincing reasons for his conclusion. His book is well referenced and very informative. He has written objectively, which is a feat in itself. Many books on this subject are emotional and biased according to views of writers, who are more motivated by their ideology rather than presenting the truth and being objective. This book was written in 2014 and takes the reader up to the Gaza War. It, therefore, is a bit dated as much has happened after that. The Middle East and Israel are dynamic and the situation does change. However, the problems remain unchanged.
While I’m sure some will argue that Pogrund is too evenly-handed in his approach, I believe this is what gives the book its credibility. ‘Drawing Fire’ will not please those adherents of the maxim - “my country right or wrong".I contend that it is essential reading for those who are willing to approach the question with an open mind.In my view, anyone wishing to arm themselves effectively with the relevant facts to counter the apartheid canard should read ‘Drawing Fire’. It should be compulsory reading for students of history, political science and those advocates for Israel, whether serving in NGOs or Israel’s diplomatic service.Sir Harold Evan’s says it succinctly and poignantly in the foreword:"Everyone who cares about how Palestinians and Israelis may live together should read this compelling book.â€
This is a thoroughly researched book from a writer who chooses to be as impartial as possible, which is rare in today's discussions of Israel. The book was dense with facts, but easy to read and the writer made his point, that Israel is NOT an apartheid state, without white washing what Israel does wrong. He shows both side, and how they have intersected in their history. He is very fair in his assessment of this subject.
Backed by statistics and well researched, this book will change and inform attitudes for both Jews and non-Jews, and destroy many preconceived ideas about Israel, the occupation of the West Bank and the way forward for Israel and the Palestinians.
If you want a compilation of Israeli government arguments as to why Israel is not an apartheid state, this is a very handy reference volume. Pogrund has long stood as Israel's propagandist-in-chief on this topic, partly because he can bring to the debate his background as a former South African academic who claims, on this basis, superior insight about what apartheid truly is. In actuality, his analysis is a patchwork of polemics and random arguments drawing from everywhere except the most authoritative source, which is international law. Instead, he tends to emphasize practices and appearances (such as voting rights, which differ from the South African system) rather than definitions of apartheid developed by the international community (for which the significance of voting rights is contingent on whether they actually serve or relieve racial domination). Indeed, Pogrund doesn't engage with law effectively here at all. The book consists of several essays he's written over the years, glued together with transition material to make them into a book, but is mostly polemical and also reflects his own biases that contradict stark evidence. For example, he casts the entire settlement project in the occupied territories as the work of crazed extremists, instead of the coherent and official state-led project that it obviously is. He also repeatedly mixes up the situation of Palestinian citizens of Israel and Palestinians living under occupation, and sometimes wanders off into ad hominem denunciations of various authors taking a different view. Again, this volume is useful in providing Israeli government arguments, especially for those seeking talking points to defend Israel against charges of apartheid, but for those seeking an academic or otherwise evidence- and theory-driven analysis, this book will be of limited use except as a reference.
Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel PDF
Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel EPub
Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel Doc
Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel iBooks
Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel rtf
Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel Mobipocket
Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel Kindle
0 comments:
Post a Comment